Shows like Stranger Things bottle a very specific feeling: a small town where something impossible is happening just out of sight, a group of kids (or outcasts) who notice first, and a synth-heavy sense that the past is never really past. The picks below share that DNA in different ways — some lean into time travel, some into monsters, some into pure 80s nostalgia. Start with Dark if you want the smartest, most intricate version of the formula, or with Stranger Things itself if you have somehow never been to Hawkins.
The Closest Matches
Dark (2017) is the essential next watch. In the German town of Winden, a missing boy unravels a web of time travel spanning four families and several generations. It is darker and more demanding than Stranger Things — every episode adds a layer — but the payoff is one of the most satisfying puzzles in television.
Stranger Things (2016) remains the benchmark: Will Byers vanishes from Hawkins, Indiana in 1983, his friends find a girl with powers, and a parallel dimension called the Upside Down starts bleeding through. Five seasons of bikes, basements and monsters, and the rare blockbuster that keeps its heart intact.
From (2022) takes the small-town trap literally: a town nobody can leave, where the roads loop back and the night brings things that wear familiar faces. It is scarier than Stranger Things and more mystery-driven, with a new question every episode.
Wednesday (2022) trades the small town for a school for outcasts, but the formula rhymes: a sardonic teen outsider, a monster mystery, and a cast of misfits who become a found family. It is lighter, funnier and hugely rewatchable.
More Small-Town Supernatural Picks
Twin Peaks is the grandfather of the whole genre: an FBI agent investigates a murder in a logging town where nothing is what it seems, and the weirdness never lets up. The X-Files pairs monster-of-the-week chills with a mythology that defined 90s television, and its small-town episodes are the best entry point. Gravity Falls hides its supernatural secrets inside a summer vacation cartoon that is far smarter and stranger than it looks. And Locke & Key turns a family home full of magical keys into a coming-of-age story with real bite.
Why the Formula Works
Small towns work for supernatural stories because everyone knows everyone — which means every secret matters and every disappearance is personal. The best shows here use that intimacy: the horror is not just the monster, it is what the monster reveals about the town. And the 80s setting, real or evoked, adds a layer of nostalgia that makes the scares land harder, because the world feels simpler right up until it is not.
The other secret is the ensemble. Stranger Things works because you care about the whole party, not just the hero; Dark works because its families feel real across decades. When the kids on bikes (or their equivalents) stand together against something impossible, the show earns its emotional climax.
Where to Start Tonight
If you want the deepest rabbit hole, Dark is unmatched — give it three episodes and it will own your weekend. If you want scares, From is the pick. If you want fun, Wednesday delivers immediately. And if you have not yet finished Stranger Things itself, the fifth and final season is the natural destination before anything else.
For the full story behind the smartest pick on this list, see the complete Dark page.
One More Reason to Love the Genre
The small-town supernatural show is also the most rewatchable kind of television. Once you know the answers, a second viewing turns every background detail into a clue: the strange neighbor, the odd symbol, the line of dialogue that meant nothing the first time. Dark rewards rewatches more than almost any show ever made, and Stranger Things is built for the same treatment — its foreshadowing is everywhere once you know where to look. That is why these shows build such devoted fan communities: the mystery is not just watched, it is solved together.
For the full story behind the smartest pick on this list, see the complete Dark page.









